Her release was all over both of us and soaking into the bedding. Once she settled, I pulled back with a grin on my face. She was panting from the excitement of riding her high.
“I-I’m sorry.”
I wiped my face clean with the corner of the blanket. “You made a mess.”
Her face turned bright red, and I could tell that she really had no idea what her body was capable of. Her eyes filled withunshed tears, and she covered her face with both hands. I was quick to pull them away.
“Look at me.”
She refused to open her eyes.
“I said, look at me.”
She hesitated, but slowly opened her eyes to look at me.
“Don’t ever hide when you’re with me, understand? Tell me.”
“Yes,” she whispered in a trembling voice.
“You’re mine now, and I want it all. You have no reason to feel embarrassed. What happened… that’s exactly what I wanted to happen.”
Her brow lifted. “You mean, you wanted me to…” she whispered.
I grinned. “I want that and so much more.” I took my dick in hand and positioned myself so my shaft was lying against her blushing, wet pussy. I thrust forward and pulled back, coating myself in her arousal. “Are you on birth control?”
She bit her lip and nodded.
“Do you want me inside you?” I asked, rocking against her again.
She nodded again.
“That’s not good enough this time. I need to hear you say it.”
“I want you inside me, Eli.”
With that, I pulled back, aligned my tip at her entrance, and pushed forward, all in one fluid-like motion.
I pushed slowly into her, ripping away her innocence inch by delicious inch. Her body tightened with every movement deeper into her small body, and her back arched as she let out a shriek of pain as I forced the rest of my cock to the hilt in her hot, tight pussy. She was so small, and I definitely wasn’t. A virgin taking a cock the size of mine had to be painful.
Tears filled her eyes and quickly rolled over the rims. I didn’t dare move inside her. I just cupped her cheeks and rested my forehead against hers.
“Shhhh, it’s okay. The pain will fade away now,” I assured her as I licked away her tears and kissed her face.
“It hurts,” she whimpered. “Please, Eli.”
“It’s OK,” I assured her softly. “It’s OK, Evie.”
The longer I stayed still inside her, the more her body relaxed around me. I kissed her forehead, cheeks, and neck, making my way to her mouth. When she began to kiss me back, that’s when I knew she was ready. I started to move my hips, slowly, only taking shallow strokes at first. She was so fucking hot and tight around me that I was suddenly glad I had already gotten off. If I hadn’t, I knew I never would’ve lasted.
She started to kiss me harder, faster. She dug her nails into my back, silently giving me the okay to move at a quicker pace. As badly as I wanted to just fuck her as rough as I could, something inside of me wouldn’t let me. It wasn’t about getting off anymore. It was about wanting to be there with her for as long as fucking possible. I wanted to hit pause on the world so I could spend an eternity with her like this. Everything felt right. I was exactly where I was meant to be. The plan for revenge was nothing but a distant memory. The pain Gabe caused me was finally gone. It was the first time that the past no longer mattered. Then reality sunk in.
I was in love with little Evie Ashford.
EVELYN
The look in his eyes was serious.
The way he was touching me, the way he was moving inside me, it all said that this wasn’t just for fun. There was so much between us already. Years of history, memories, and it had pulled us closer together, even when I didn’t expect it to. I looked into his steel-gray eyes as he moved inside of me, and all signs of Professor West were gone.
