Page 89 of Replay


Font Size:

She grinned and slid far enough up to kiss me. Our tongues met, twisted, and I was lost in the taste and feel of her.

Then I realized the wiggling wasn’t just about the kiss as the head of my dick started to slide into her tight pussy. She groaned, or I did, or we both did. It felt incredible, beyond anything I’d experienced. Something flickered in the back of my brain, but it was lost as she slid down until my dick was completely inside her.

“Fuck, Katie.”

She pushed herself up till she was straddling my hips. Every move stimulated those nerves, and I battled to keep from coming. She wanted this, and I didn’t want to end the fun early.

She drew a shaky breath. “Ready?” Her voice was raspy, the turned-on version of her that I’d jerked off to so many times.

I nodded and gripped her hips.

She braced her hands on my chest and lifted up. I hated the loss of her heat, but then she dropped down, deeper, and I moaned. She twisted her hips and shuddered.

I wasn’t going to last long. I couldn’t, not after going down on her and having her mouth on me. I didn’t want to leave her hanging, so I moved my fingers to her clit and gently rubbed.

“Josh!” She lifted and dropped again, and I pressed on her.

We repeated, each time her body shaking harder.

“Josh, I’m gonna…gonna.”

I pressed and shoved my hips up and then got to watch my favorite thing—Katie coming. Her head tossed back, her eyes closed, her mouth open as she shouted my name. Her pussy clenched on me and I was done. My own eyes closed, and I shouted her name as I shot inside her, every cell in my body climaxing.

Katie dropped on my chest. Her panting breath brushed my shoulder, and her sweaty skin slicked against mine. My dick softened, and slid out of her, with my come.

“Shit!” That’s what my brain had been trying to tell me. Katie blinked at me. “We didn’t use a condom.”

Her eyes went big, the orgasm high leaving them. “Shit,” she repeated.

“I’m sorry, Katie. So sorry.”

She shook her head. “I’m the one who slid onto you without waiting. It was like…”

“Yeah.” It was like old times. Back in high school. We’d been each other’s firsts, and once she was on birth control, we didn’t always use the condom.

Her forehead was frowning again, and I hated doing that to her. “Um, we get tested, by the team, and I was negative the last time. And I haven’t been with anyone since.”

Normally I would have. If I hadn’t tried to hook up with her roommate, and then, once I’d seen Katie again, no one else interested me.

Her eyes scanned my face. “I had a complete physical before school started. There’s been no one. I’m on birth control.”

“So, you’re okay?” I couldn’t believe I might have risked her future, or her health. Thank fuck I was always careful—except around Katie.

She nodded.

“I’m sorry. I won’t do that again.”

Her forehead smoothed. “Actually, I hope you do a lot of that again. But we should use condoms. What with my family history and all.”

I nodded. She had plans and dreams and I didn’t want to interfere with them. Her family would freak and hate me forever. And depriving Katie of what she wanted wasn’t happening.

Condoms were a smart idea. We’d been fine in high school, but I wouldn’t risk her. Not ever.

Chapter 27

One Step Closer to Leaving

Katie