Page 171 of Hat Trick
Lexi tumbles over the edge next after she rubs her clit against the sheets, and I hold her in place until I know I’m finished doing exactly what she asked. Every part of my body is sensitive and alive, and I collapse forward when she wiggles out from underneath me and flops onto her stomach.
“Ten out of ten. Five stars. Would fuck again,” I say, finding my glasses and putting them back on. She takes my hand in hers and I open an eye when I feel her moving my palm over her body. “I thought you finished. Do you need my fingers?”
“No.” She guides my fingers to her pussy and works my pointer finger inside her. “I want you to feel what you did to me.”
“Holy hell.” I scramble across the sheets so I can get a better look, and Icanfeel what I did to her. The warm, sticky mess I made, and when I pull my finger out, I smear the cum clinging to my knuckle on the inside of her thigh. “Your sexuality is such a turn on.”
“Some people have told me I’m too bold.” Lexi brings my finger to her mouth and closes her lips around it. I whimper when she drags her tongue up to the tip, sucking the digit dry. “I like that I can be myself with you.”
“You’ll never be too bold. Ever. And if there’s something you want to try, tell me, Lex. Because chances are, I want to try it too.”
“Look how compatible we are, Mitchy.” She rolls onto her side then hesitates, something weighing on her mind. “Are you my boyfriend now?”
I don’t dare move a muscle, afraid this might be a trap. I suck in a slow, intentional breath, careful as I ask my next question even though my heart is about to beat out of my chest with excitement.
“Do you… want me to be your boyfriend? We don’t have to put a label on anything.”
“I said I’d give this a try, and that means calling you my boyfriend. Fuck buddy doesn’t feel right anymore. Not when you do all these nice things for me.”
“No.” I tuck a piece of loose hair behind her ear. I’m probably grinning like a goddamn fool. “It doesn’t.”
“What do we do now?”
“We’ve had sleepovers before, Lex.” I laugh. “Did you forget all the times I’ve fallen asleep at your apartment?”
“Yeah, at my apartment. I’ve never slept over at a boyfriend’s place before. This is new territory for me.”
“Okay, well, it’s the exact same as it is at your place. And the other times you’ve dozed off here. Except my bathroom floors are heated, and I’m going to make us a grilled cheese after we take a bath.”
“Really?” Lexi lights up. “We have to be careful with our tattoos. I don’t want to ruin it already.”
“We’ll keep our arms over our heads. It’s going to be great.” I tug her toward me and kiss her. She swipes her tongue across my bottom lip and I open my mouth, the aftertaste of my cum still lingering on her tongue. “There are going to be french fries, too.”
“I’m still thinking about that pizza we ordered earlier. The server probably thought we were high. Two types of onions, three types of peppers, and four types of meat? There’s going to be a Reddit thread about us tomorrow.”
I laugh and close my eyes. “Always have to keep them guessing is what I say.”
“That’s a good motto to have.” She touches my chest, and I relax under the soft brush of her fingers against my skin. “Riley?”
“Hm?”
“Today was a really good day. And the best date I’ve ever had. I… I can’t wait to see what we do on our second date.”
“A really good day,” I agree. “But they’re all good days with you, Lexi baby.”
FORTY-SIX
RILEY
Me
I think I’m ready to get back on the ice.
Lexi
Yeah?
Me
