“But I thought you said he was going to blow a gasket,” the curvy girl sniffles. “I don’t want that!”
My brother and I share a look.
“No, we were exaggerating,” I say gently while taking one of her hands in my own big fist. “You see, Jack wants the world to be a certain way, but what he doesn’t understand is that you can’t control other people. Human beings are funny things, and they tend to move sideways when you least expect it.”
“What do you mean?” Natalie sniffles.
I lean back and share another look with my brother.
“Well, I think Jack is a very conflicted person,” I begin. “Don’t get me wrong. He wants to be a great dad, but what he wants and what you want are different. He wants you to be an angel, and yet also be a member of Dads and Daughters. Yet, you’ve taken to the club like a duck to water, and sweetheart, that makes us very, very happy.”
Natalie takes a deep shuddering breath, and looks at us. She’s so beautiful, even if her brown eyes are still shining with tears.
“But what’s your role in all this?” she asks. “I don’t understand.”
Gary speaks then.
“Well, when girls are initiated into Dads and Daughters, usually there’s a formal presentation. The daughter is “unveiled” so to say, to the dads of the group, and then she’s taken to a private space to be initiated by the father of her choice. But in your case, it was clear that that wasn’t going to fly. You know your dad submitted you for membership several times, Sugar? And he pulled back your application a few times too.”
The curvy girl looks stunned.
“No, I didn’t know that. Jack only told me about Dads and Daughters two weeks ago. I had no idea he was that conflicted about me joining.”
We nod knowingly.
“It’s a difficult transition for some fathers. They still see their little girls as babies, basically, and have a hard time accepting that those babies have grown up into ripe, fertile women. But the point is that Jack was utterly tormented, and we could see him going back and forth on this issue. The entire club could see it. So instead, Sienna and Layla took matters into their own hands.”
That makes Natalie gasp.
“It was Sienna and Layla who did this?”
I grin.
“Yes, sweetheart. The other girls only want what’s best for you, so they set up a different initiation. With the club’s blessing of course. My brother Gary and I initiated you using glory holes. We figured it was an easier way to see if you were a fit. If you were shocked and horrified, then fine. We would find another approach. But instead, you loved it, sweetheart, and we loved being with you. I can confirm that your sugar walls are sweet, tight, and perfect for the club.”
Natalie stares at us, her mouth dropping open.
“That was my initiation?”
My brother nods seriously.
“Yes, and you passed with flying colors, sweetheart. Your sugar walls stroked every last drop of seed out from Gascon and I, and in fact, we’d like to make a proposition.”
Natalie shakes her head, looking dazed.
“But this is all happening so fast!” she protests.
I nod.
“I know, baby, but if you want another initiation, we can talk about that. Some girls like the pomp and circumstance of the formal rites, as well as the sense of induction. We can arrange it, if you like.”
Natalie is still blinking and looking stunned.
“Um, I have to think about that,” she murmurs.
My brother takes her other hand in his own, so that we’re each holding one of the sweet girl’s hands.
“Natalie, we had a great time with you,” he says slowly. “In fact, Gascon and I have been looking for a woman for quite a while now. We want someone ripe, plush, and gorgeous, and you fit the bill.”
“You more than fit the bill,” I add. “You’re giving, soft, and willing, and you have all the traits that we’re looking for in a long-term relationship. I know this is fast, but would you consider it, Sugar? We’d love to be your long-term lovers, if you’re open to the idea.”
“We’re not bad looking,” Gary quips with a silly smile. “Gascon should get to the gym more often, but I promise, you’ll always have twelve abs to count at night.”
I roll my eyes at him.
“Well, someone needs to stop eating pizza, so I wouldn’t talk,” I grunt. But then I turn back to Natalie. “I know that this is really sudden because you just had your initiation, sweetheart. But would you consider it? We’d love to be with you more often, and the chemistry between the three of us is off the charts. You’ve passed your initiation with flying colors, Natalie, and let us guide you as you begin your journey.”
The curvy is still stunned and her pouty pink lips part with what I’m sure will be a no. But then, to my surprise, she nods and smiles sweetly.
