He looked quietly elated when he nodded, coming to sit beside me so he could snuggle me against his side, that strong arm wrapping around my shoulders where it belonged.
“We’re not as artistic, and we’re not…well, neither of us is Daphne’s real dad. But we wanted to get something for you too,” Luca stepped up next, pulling a small box from his pocket. Not ring-shaped, thank God, but small enough that I suspected jewelry anyway. “This is…um, for you.”
“From both of us,” Gavin clarified. “All three, really.”
“You guys didn’t have to get me anything,” I said through a watery smile.
“We know,” Gavin said. He shrugged. “But we’re all new to the romantic gesture thing, so we thought this was a good first step.”
Luca passed me the box, and I opened it to find a delicate gold chain, three little stars hanging from it.
“This is gorgeous.”
“It’s…kind of a joke,” Luca said, which confused me for a second. “A pun! We, um, said we’d give you space.”
“Hence the stars,” Gavin finished, scrubbing the back of his head with his hand, clearly nervous. I couldn’t resist now. I leapt from the sofa and threw my arms around Luca and Gavin’s necks, pulling them into my embrace. Cade stood up to join too. Another complete group hug, and this time, I was almost lightheaded with love for these three guys. Suddenly, I had no other choice but to tell them how I felt. No matter how scary it was to say the words.
“I love you,” I gasped out, pressing my face to Gavin’s chest. All three of them stilled, then pulled back, their eyes locking onto my face.
“What did you say?” Luca nearly whispered.
“I love you,” I said again, looking into his eyes, holding his gaze as the words sank in. Then, I turned to Gavin. “I love you.”Dark eyes that flashed, the hint of that dangerous smirk. I loved him. And then I was back on Cade’s blue eyes, the blue that mixed perfectly with mine and helped create Daphne’s. “I love you. All three of you. I want to do this, and screw whatever I’ve told myself in the past, and screw what the world might think. I’m yours, and you’re mine, if you want to be.”
And then I was being kissed hard and long and full of fervor. Gavin first, who pulled back with a half-growled “I love you,” and then by Luca, who said “I love you” before he put his lips to mine. I was nearly dizzy from it when it was Cade’s turn, and then I was kissing him, my hand coming up to feel his beard, and he pulled back long enough to say “I love you too.”
It felt like a beginning, something entirely new, when we made our way to my bedroom. I assured my guys that I wanted them, needed to feel each of them inside me, that I was feeling fine. Better than fine, really. Three sets of hands peeled my clothes off of my body, leaving me breathless and naked and spread out like a feast across my own bed, looking up at three men who loved me.
“I love you,” I told them all again, and Gavin swooped in to kiss me again, only this time he went for the lips between my legs.
The second his tongue met my pussy, I sighed, throwing my head back against the pillows. These three men had my heart, but it was still miraculous how well they had my body too. I was already wet, only getting wetter as Gavin licked through every crevice of my sex in slow, deliberate motions. He was so controlled, just like always, but there was a layer of generosity to it, like he was putting in all this effort to give me the most pleasure possible. Not because he wanted the control, but because he knew he had it, and he wanted to do right by me.
By the time his tongue was circling my clit, avoiding touching it directly and making me gasp out needy pleas as he held myhips down to keep them from grinding, guiding him where I needed him, my other two guys had joined us, one on either side of me. Luca kissed me hard on the lips as his hand cupped my right breast with reverence akin to worship. And Cade’s beard, so deliciously rough against my oversensitive flesh, lightly scraped my left breast as he moved in to suck the stiff peak into his mouth. All the while, his big hand was caressing my belly, as if he could thank me retroactively for giving him the child he now knew was his.
“I love you,” I sobbed against Luca’s mouth when Cade’s teeth lightly bit down at my sensitive nipple. At the same time, Gavin’s wicked tongue finally struck gold, flicking against my clit in exactly the way I needed. He growled, burying his face further into me, letting me know how delicious he found my pussy. How much he loved it. Loved me.
When I came apart, I cried out, and the guys all praised me. Told me I was beautiful, that I was perfect, that they loved me.
“I love watching you come apart for us,” Luca told me, unexpectedly dirty with his words but so perfectly sweet with his tone and his pinked cheeks. “You’re the most beautiful woman any of us has ever seen, Allie.” He leaned in closer to press his lips to the shell of my ear, and he whispered, only for me, “I’m so lucky that you’re the only woman I’ve ever touched. The only woman I’ll ever touch again.”
I whimpered, partly at the beautiful sentiment, and partly because Gavin had finished licking me through my orgasm. He pulled his mouth away, but before I could protest, could beg one of my other guys to take his place, the hard, full head of his cock was sliding home inside me.
“Yes,” I cried out as Gavin fit into me like a perfect puzzle piece. “Yes, Gavin. Please, come inside me. Show me how much you love me.”
“With pleasure, gorgeous,” his rough voice ground out, and he took up a decadent pace, filling me up with his length again and again.
I needed more. Wished that I could take all three of their cocks at once again, but I knew there would be time. Still, my hands roamed, sliding down to Cade and Luca’s groins. With a little adjustment, a little cooperation from the two of them and some more shedding of clothes, they were bare and standing proud on either side of me, and I took each of them, one perfect erection in each of my hands.
“Fuck,” Cade swore when I slid my thumb over his precum-slick tip. He leaned back in, taking my mouth in a searing kiss this time while Luca took up the task of sucking my neglected breast, wetting my straining nipple and then making me moan into Cade’s kiss when he blew cool air over the flesh, pebbling it. Another orgasm was already creeping up, but I was still surprised when Luca’s fingers found my clit and Gavin picked up his pace, and I knew I was done for. Faster than I’d ever come before, I felt myself rocket into another climax, and it was all I could do not to pass out from the pleasure of it.
“Fuck, I’m coming,” Gavin grunted. It was orgasmic on its own, hearing him losing control. I felt it when he came inside me, hot and fast and intimate as he thrust in deep and held himself inside me. I felt every twitch, every spasm.
It was with perfect efficiency that Luca took Gavin’s place, swapping one man I loved for another. I wanted all of them to have their turn inside me, and that seemed to be their ideal too. When Luca first thrust into my channel, he groaned at the feeling of my own orgasm’s aftershocks. My inner muscles were still flickering, still demanding more even as Luca’s cock was aided in its slick slides by Gavin’s cum. The gorgeous man who had given me his virginity took up the mantle of pleasuring my body and his with a passion that I admired. A passion I shared.
Gavin’s tongue was in my mouth, Cade’s enormous cock in my hand, and Luca was making love to me. There was no greater happy ending for me, for any of us. I succumbed to the waves of pleasure, arching and bowing into each of the three men’s skillful, sweet touches.
Gavin kissed from my jaw down my throat to the valley between my breasts. I sighed as he nuzzled, then sucked, teased my already aching tits. And in that moment, I locked eyes with Cade, then looked down at the masculine beauty of his hardness. I licked my lips, and told him, “Please.”
He looked so in love with me I wanted to cry again. But I was too overwhelmed with the pleasure I was receiving to do it, and that was for the best, because when Cade moved to bring his swollen tip to my lips, I knew I’d have tears streaming in a second anyway. He was so big, filling my mouth so perfectly, and I sucked him deep, relishing the way he stroked into me. It was delicious to gag around his girth. But I only got in a few good sucks, a few long, primal moans around his heat, before Luca was crying out with his own release too.
